Reviews policy

How reviews of art organizations work on ArtConnect. Last updated 16 November 2026.

Artists decide where to send their work, their money and sometimes a year of their life on very little information. Almost nobody who knows what an organization is like to deal with says so publicly, because they may need to apply again. Reviews exist to close that gap. They are written for other artists, and this page explains exactly how they work.

What can be reviewed

Organization profiles — residencies, galleries, institutions, foundations, art fairs, publications and universities. A review is attached to the organization, not to a single open call: a call closes, the organization carries on, and it is the organization's conduct that matters. Where a review is about one particular programme, it records which and when, and that is shown with it.

Individual artists, curators and collectors cannot be reviewed. This is one-directional by design.

An organization does not have to have an ArtConnect account to be reviewed, and does not have to agree to it. It can always reply, and that is free.

Who can write one

  • You have an ArtConnect account and are signed in.
  • Your account is an artist or curator account.
  • You personally had a direct, first-hand experience with the organization — not a friend's, not something you were told, not something you read.
  • The experience happened within the last 10 years.

Ten years rather than the twelve months a consumer review site would use. An open call closes, a jury sits, a residency runs eighteen months later, and the artist only knows how it went at the end; a one-year window would exclude most of what is worth reporting. There is a limit at all because an older experience is less likely to describe the organization as it is now — and every review shows when the experience happened, so you can weigh it yourself.

What counts as an experience

  • Applied — you submitted an application. Includes being rejected, and includes never hearing back.
  • Selected and took part — residency, programme, exhibition, commission, award.
  • Exhibited — your work was shown by them.
  • Represented — they represented or sold your work.
  • Worked with them — taught, performed, consulted, collaborated, or were otherwise professionally engaged.

Not an experience: visiting as a member of the public, attending an opening, buying a ticket, following them online, or hearing about them from someone else.

What you can speak to depends on which you choose. If you applied and were not selected, you can speak to the application — how clear the call was, the fees, the communication, whether they decided when they said they would. You cannot speak to the studios or the stipend, because you were not there. That is not a limit on criticism; it is what makes the ratings mean anything.

What a review has to be

  • Your own experience, described as your own. Say what happened to you.
  • Checkable where it is factual. "They advertised a €1,500 stipend and paid €900" is a fact you could point to. If you state something as fact, be ready to show it.
  • About the organization, not about a named person. Criticise the process, the terms, the communication. Please don't name staff, jurors or other artists — we remove individuals' names.
  • Honest about what you don't know. If you suspect something, say that you suspect it.

One review per person per organization, and the date is shown. If you want it changed or taken down, email reviews@artconnect.com.

What we don't publish

  • Reviews that aren't about a first-hand experience.
  • Personal attacks, abuse, slurs, or anything targeting someone's identity.
  • Named individuals.
  • Contact details, addresses or personal data — yours or anyone's.
  • Reviews of an organization you own, work for, sit on the board of, or compete with.
  • Reviews you were paid or rewarded for. Being asked is fine — we invite people to review, and organizations may invite their own participants. Being given something in exchange is not.
  • Marketing, spam, or links to commercial services.
  • The same review copied onto many organizations.

Allegations of unlawful conduct — harassment, assault, discrimination, fraud, theft, safety offences — are not published as reviews. That is not us dismissing them. A public star rating is the wrong instrument for a serious allegation: it cannot be investigated properly, it exposes you personally, and it helps nobody if it comes down a week later. Contact us directly instead, where a person reads it, you keep control of what is shared, and we can act on patterns across several reports.

How reviews are checked — and what we don't check

What we always do

  • Every reviewer has a confirmed ArtConnect account. There are no anonymous drive-by reviews.
  • Automated checks run on every review before it appears, against the rules on this page — not against whether it flatters anyone. Reviews those checks flag, and anything that may allege unlawful conduct, are held for a person to read.
  • While this feature is new, a person reads every review before it appears. That is a temporary stage rather than the permanent design, and we will say so here when it changes.
  • We never alter the words of a review, never reorder reviews to flatter anyone, and never remove a review for being negative.

What we don't do

We do not verify in advance that an experience happened, and we cannot: artists apply through organizations' own websites, not through ArtConnect, so we hold no record of who applied where. Every review is self-reported unless it carries a label saying otherwise.

What triggers a real check

If an organization challenges a review, we ask the reviewer to show evidence that the experience happened — an acceptance or rejection email, a contract, correspondence, an invoice, a public listing. If nothing arrives within the deadline, the review comes down. If evidence does arrive, the review stays and is labelled as verified.

A Verified label means we have seen evidence of the relationship — that this artist did have this experience with this organization. It does not mean we have checked every statement or opinion in the review. We will never show it without having actually seen evidence.

What organizations can do

Any organization, whether or not it has an ArtConnect account:

  • Reply publicly, once per review, under its own name. The reply sits with the review and is never hidden. It is free, and it always will be.
  • Report a review that breaks one of the rules on this page, with a reason.

What no organization can do, at any price: have a review removed for being unflattering or commercially inconvenient, have it moved down the page, or have it hidden behind other reviews. Payment does not influence review scores, publication, verification, how a report is handled, or whether a review is removed. A report from an organization that pays us is decided by exactly the same rules as one from an organization that has never given us anything.

Challenging a review

  1. The organization reports the review and says which rule it breaks.
  2. We acknowledge within 2 working days.
  3. If the objection is that the experience never happened, we ask the reviewer for evidence and give them 21 days. If the objection is that the review breaks a content rule, we decide on the text itself.
  4. We tell both sides the outcome and which rule it turned on.
  5. Either side can ask us to look again.

We aim to decide promptly and to treat serious or clearly unlawful content urgently. Complicated cases take longer, and we would rather be accurate than fast.

Disagreeing with a review is not a ground. "We remember it differently" is what the public reply is for.

Your name on your review

Reviews are published under your profile name and link to your profile. Reviewing an organization you may need again is a real risk, and we are not going to pretend otherwise — it is exactly why so little of this information exists publicly today.

You can turn the name off. There is a control on the form, "Don't show my name". Your review then shows your relationship and the date instead of your name, with no link to your profile.

Hiding your name is a display setting, not anonymity. Your review stays linked to your account so that we can confirm it is genuine if an organization ever challenges it — which protects you, because it is what stops an organization simply asserting the review was invented. We do not share your identity with the organization, and we would only ever be required to use it in a formal challenge or where the law obliges us.

On a small programme, hiding your name may not be enough. A residency with eight participants means "took part, spring 2025" nearly identifies you, and the organization can often work it out. We would rather say that plainly than imply a protection we cannot give.

We will not build a page listing everything you have written. Reviews link to the organization, never out to a list of your other reviews. An organization should not be able to look up an artist and see that they leave critical reviews.

Changing your mind

Email reviews@artconnect.com and we will take your review down, for any reason and with no questions asked. Removing it takes it off the organization's page and out of its rating, and you are free to write a new one afterwards.

Editing a published review yourself is not something we offer yet. Every review is read by a person before it appears, and an edit that published itself unread would go straight around that. Ask us and we will take the old one down so you can write it again.

Reporting something

Every review has a Report this review link. You do not need an account to report content you believe is unlawful. If you give us an email address we will confirm we received it and tell you what we decided; without one we have no way to reply, though we will still assess it.